Transcendental Meditation (TM) has gained popularity over the years for its claimed benefits on mental and emotional well-being. There has been ongoing debate surrounding whether TM can be classified as a cult. Before delving into that discussion, let’s first understand what defines a cult and the common traits associated with it.

A cult is typically characterized by its distinct belief system, charismatic leader, and the implementation of manipulative tactics to control and influence its members. Common traits of cults include isolation from mainstream society, strict adherence to certain doctrines, and the exploitation of its members for financial or personal gain.

Now, let’s explore what Transcendental Meditation actually entails. TM is a form of meditation technique that originated in India in the 1950s and was popularized in the West by Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. It involves the practice of silently repeating a mantra to achieve a state of deep relaxation and mental clarity. Supporters of TM claim that it can reduce stress, promote inner peace, and enhance overall well-being.

The debate on whether TM should be considered a cult stems from various perspectives. Some argue that certain aspects of TM, such as the reverence towards the founder and the strict adherence to its principles, align with characteristics commonly associated with cults. On the other hand, proponents of TM argue that it does not possess the harmful elements typically found in cults and emphasize the scientific research and studies that support its effectiveness.

Allegations and criticisms against TM focus on manipulative tactics, financial exploitation, and the potential social and emotional impact on its followers. These concerns have fueled the ongoing controversy surrounding TM.

To evaluate the validity of these allegations, it is essential to analyze the scientific research and studies conducted on TM, as well as seek expert opinions and personal testimonials from individuals who have practiced it. This evidence can provide valuable insights into the nature of TM and its impact on practitioners.

Ultimately, the question of whether Transcendental Meditation is a cult requires a thorough examination of the available information, personal experiences, and perspectives. By objectively and critically analyzing the evidence from all angles, we can arrive at a more informed conclusion.

Key Takeaway:

  • Transcendental Meditation maximizes mental well-being: Practicing Transcendental Meditation allows individuals to achieve a state of deep relaxation and reduce stress, promoting better mental health.
  • Understanding the characteristics of cults: By examining the traits and defining factors of cults, we can evaluate whether Transcendental Meditation meets these criteria or not.
  • Evaluating the evidence: Scientific research, expert opinions, and personal experiences play a crucial role in determining whether Transcendental Meditation should be considered a cult or not.

Understanding Cults

Understanding Cults

Cults are social groups that revolve around a charismatic leader and promote beliefs or practices that deviate from societal norms. To recognize and navigate potentially harmful situations, it is important to understand the characteristics and dynamics of cults.

1. Manipulation: Cult leaders use tactics to control their followers, such as isolating them from family and friends, creating dependence on the leader or group, and instilling fear or guilt to discourage questioning of cult beliefs or practices.

2. Mind Control: Cults employ techniques to influence the thoughts, attitudes, and behaviors of their members. These techniques include thought-stopping, repetitive rituals, and the use of propaganda and indoctrination to reinforce the cult’s ideology.

3. Groupthink: Cults discourage critical thinking and praise conformity, leading to a loss of individual identity and reliance on the group for validation and decision-making.

4. Exploitation: Cults may exploit members financially, emotionally, or sexually. Leaders demand large sums of money or excessive donations and manipulate members into engaging in sexual relationships or other forms of exploitation.

5. Secrecy: Cults operate in secrecy, limiting exposure to external influences and controlling the flow of information within the group. This makes it difficult for outsiders to understand the beliefs and practices of the cult and for members to seek help or support from the outside world.

6. Emotional Manipulation: Cult leaders cultivate emotional dependency among their followers, using techniques like love bombing to create a sense of belonging and loyalty. This emotional manipulation makes it difficult for members to leave the cult.

7. Destructive Beliefs: Cults may hold harmful or dangerous beliefs, such as promoting violence, self-harm, or cutting off contact with critical friends and family. These beliefs negatively impact the mental and physical well-being of cult members.

Understanding cults is crucial for recognizing signs of manipulation and exploitation. By educating ourselves about cult dynamics and characteristics, we can better protect ourselves and others from potentially harmful situations.

What Defines a Cult?

A cult is defined by several key factors that set it apart from mainstream society. These defining characteristics include charismatic leaders, manipulative tactics, mind control techniques, financial exploitation, and social and emotional impact.

Charismatic leaders play a pivotal role in cults, as they possess absolute power and are highly revered within the group. Cults often employ manipulative tactics to control and influence their members. These tactics may involve isolating individuals from their social circles, controlling access to information, and using fear and guilt to maintain control.

Mind control is another significant aspect of cults, with techniques aimed at manipulating the thoughts and behaviors of members. These techniques can include the repetition of specific beliefs, discouraging critical thinking, and the use of thought-stopping techniques.

Financial exploitation is prevalent in many cults, with members required to make substantial financial contributions or surrender their possessions. These contributions are typically used to sustain the cult and enrich its leaders.

Cults also have a significant social and emotional impact on their members, fostering a strong sense of community and belonging. While this offers support and purpose, it can also lead to emotional dependence and isolation from the outside world.

It is crucial to note that not all groups displaying these traits are necessarily cults. Context and intent are essential in determining whether a group qualifies as a cult. It is important to consider the well-being of cult members and the impact on their overall health.

Understanding the defining characteristics of a cult can empower individuals to identify and steer clear of potentially harmful groups. It is vital to be aware of manipulative tactics, maintain critical thinking skills, and seek diverse perspectives when assessing any group or organization.

Common Traits and Characteristics of Cults

The list below highlights common traits and characteristics of cults:

Cults have a charismatic leader who is the ultimate authority and may exhibit manipulative behavior.

Cults isolate members from the outside world, cutting them off from family, friends, and support systems.

Cults control members through mind control techniques, strict rules, and manipulation of information.

Cults exploit members financially, emotionally, or sexually, taking advantage of their vulnerability and trust.

Cults create an “us vs. them” mentality, viewing outsiders as enemies and emphasizing loyalty to the group.

Cults promote conformity and discourage critical thinking, pressuring individuals to conform to the group’s beliefs.

Members of cults display extreme devotion, prioritizing the group’s goals and beliefs over their own well-being.

Cults do not tolerate dissent or questioning of their beliefs, resorting to shaming, punishment, or isolation to maintain control.

Cults strip members of their individuality, replacing it with a group identity and sense of belonging only within the cult.

Cults control access to information, limiting exposure to outside ideas or criticisms.

By recognizing these common traits and characteristics of cults, individuals can better identify and avoid potentially harmful cults.

When exploring new spiritual or community groups, it is important to remain vigilant and ask critical questions. If you notice any of these common traits and characteristics of cults, it is advisable to seek further information and perspectives before fully committing to the group.

What is Transcendental Meditation?

Looking to uncover the essence of Transcendental Meditation? Delve into the intriguing world of this practice as we unveil its origin, history, principles, and techniques. Discover the fascinating roots of TM and become acquainted with the fundamental principles and techniques that make this method unique. Brace yourself for an eye-opening journey into the depths of Transcendental Meditation.

Origin and History of TM

Transcendental Meditation (TM) has a fascinating origin and history that spans several decades. In the 1950s, Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, a spiritual leader from India, developed TM and introduced it to the world. This technique, based on the ancient Vedic tradition of silent mantra repetition, was adapted by Maharishi Mahesh Yogi to cater to the modern individual’s needs for relaxation and transcendence.

During the 1960s, TM gained significant popularity, especially among celebrities like The Beatles. Maharishi Mahesh Yogi traveled extensively, bringing TM to the Western world, starting with the United States. Through lectures and training sessions, he taught countless people how to practice TM, enabling them to reduce stress, enhance concentration, and improve overall well-being.

TM has faced both acclaim and criticism over the years. While many see it as a transformative and life-changing practice, others express concerns about its commercialization and the secrecy surrounding its advanced techniques. Nevertheless, individuals from various backgrounds continue to embrace TM, seeking inner peace and personal growth.

The merits of TM have been supported by scientific research. Studies indicate that regular TM practice can effectively reduce stress levels, lower blood pressure, and enhance mental clarity. These findings have contributed to the recognition of TM as a legitimate approach to promoting health and well-being.

Principles and Techniques of TM

The principles and techniques of Transcendental Meditation (TM) can be understood through the following table:

Principles Techniques
1. Effortlessness During TM, practitioners effortlessly transcend the active thinking process and experience deeper levels of consciousness.
2. Naturalness TM allows the mind to naturally follow its tendency towards greater happiness, creativity, and intelligence.
3. Non-concentration Unlike other meditation practices, TM does not involve concentration or mind control. Instead, it encourages spontaneous and effortless diving within.
4. Transcendence The ultimate goal of TM is to reach a state of transcendental consciousness, where the mind experiences deep rest and rejuvenation.
5. Unified Field TM teaches that transcendental consciousness allows access to the unified field of all the laws of nature, promoting holistic well-being and harmony.

The techniques of TM are rooted in these principles. Practicing TM offers benefits such as reduced stress and anxiety, improved overall well-being, enhanced creativity, and increased clarity of thought. TM is a simple and effortless technique suitable for people of all ages and backgrounds.

During TM, individuals sit comfortably with their eyes closed and silently repeat a mantra given by their TM teacher. The mantra helps the mind settle into a state of transcending thought. Thoughts are not actively suppressed or avoided; instead, practitioners allow thoughts to come and go, gently and effortlessly returning attention to the mantra when the mind wanders.

It’s important to note that TM is taught through personalized instruction by certified TM teachers who provide guidance and support to ensure proper understanding and practice of the technique.

If you are interested in learning more about TM, it is recommended to seek guidance from certified TM teachers who can provide accurate and personalized instruction.

The Debate: Is Transcendental Meditation a Cult?

Let’s dive into the fiery debate surrounding Transcendental Meditation (TM) and whether it can be labeled as a cult. Brace yourself as we explore the contrasting arguments that both support and dismiss TM as a cult. From alleged manipulation tactics to profound spiritual experiences, we’ll unravel the fascinating controversy surrounding TM. So, buckle up and prepare for an enlightening journey into the realm of Transcendental Meditation – is it truly a cult?

Arguments Supporting TM as a Cult

Transcendental Meditation (TM) is a subject of debate and controversy. Some argue that it can be classified as a cult. There are valid points supporting this view.

1. Leader worship: TM practitioners idolize the founder, Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, as a spiritual leader. They follow his teachings without question.

2. Manipulative tactics: TM uses manipulative tactics to control its followers. This includes thought-stopping techniques and discouraging critical thinking, limiting individuals’ ability to make informed decisions.

3. Financial exploitation: TM programs require a significant financial investment. This can create a dependence on the organization, making individuals feel obligated to continue participating.

4. Isolation and exclusivity: TM promotes a sense of exclusivity and isolation from the wider community. Followers are encouraged to distance themselves from those who do not share their beliefs.

While these arguments raise legitimate concerns, not everyone agrees with the classification of TM as a cult. Supporters argue that it is simply a meditation technique that provides benefits such as stress reduction and improved focus. They believe the organization promotes self-improvement and personal growth.

Arguments Against TM Being a Cult

Scientific research demonstrates that Transcendental Meditation (TM) yields various benefits on mental health and well-being. Numerous studies have indicated that TM is effective in reducing stress and anxiety levels, enhancing focus and cognitive abilities, and facilitating relaxation. These findings directly contradict the notion that TM is a harmful cult, as they clearly signify positive outcomes for TM practitioners.

TM holds great regard for individuals’ freedom of choice and autonomy. Participants willingly embrace TM practices and retain the ability to discontinue their involvement whenever they desire. By respecting individual agency and choice, TM effectively challenges the perception that it functions as a cult.

Unlike cults, TM does not endorse exclusivity. Practitioners are actively encouraged to uphold their existing beliefs and engage in other activities, including various religious or spiritual practices. This inclusive approach starkly contrasts with the typical behavior exhibited by cults, further reinforcing the assertion that TM is not a cult.

TM openly and transparently states the associated costs and fees for training, demonstrating a complete absence of financial manipulation. This is in stark contrast to cults, which frequently require substantial financial contributions from their members. The clear absence of financial exploitation within TM directly contradicts the belief that it operates as a cult.

Countless individuals have reported experiencing positive personal growth and self-improvement through their practice of TM. TM aims to foster well-being, creativity, and inner peace, placing a strong emphasis on individual empowerment and personal growth. These characteristics fundamentally contradict the nature of cults, thereby reinforcing the argument against TM being classified as a cult.

The arguments presented against TM being labeled as a cult underscore the scientific evidence validating its beneficial effects, the freedom of choice conferred to practitioners, the inclusive nature of the practice, the absence of financial exploitation, and the focus on personal empowerment and growth. While debates regarding the classification of TM as a cult may persist, these arguments offer an alternative perspective that strongly challenges the prevailing cult narrative.

Examining the Allegations and Criticisms

In this section, we delve into the allegations and criticisms surrounding transcendental meditation. We’ll explore the manipulative tactics, financial exploitation, and social and emotional impact associated with this practice. Buckle up as we unravel the dark side behind the serene façade and shed light on the controversial aspects of transcendental meditation.

Manipulative Tactics and Mind Control

  • Cults use tactics to isolate members from friends and family. They discourage outside influences and promote exclusivity.
  • Cults manipulate and control the thoughts of members. They discourage critical thinking, promote unquestioning loyalty, and induce trance-like states through practices like chanting or meditation.
  • Cults control the information members have access to. They restrict internet, book, and other sources that could introduce opposing viewpoints or expose potential abuses.
  • Cults use fear and guilt to manipulate members. They instill fear of punishment and exploit existing fears or insecurities.
  • Cults exploit members’ finances. They require financial contributions, pressure for savings donations, or gain access to assets.

Pro-tip: If you suspect involvement in a cult or exposure to manipulative tactics and mind control, reach out for support. Seek assistance from trusted friends, family, or professionals for guidance.

Financial Exploitation

Financial exploitation is a significant concern when assessing whether Transcendental Meditation (TM) can be considered a cult. One example of alleged financial exploitation associated with TM is the exorbitant cost of participating in TM programs. Participants are required to pay initiation fees and subsequent course fees, which can range from hundreds to thousands of dollars, potentially leaving certain individuals financially vulnerable or in debt.

Another aspect of financial exploitation within TM centers around the organization’s accumulated wealth and financial practices. TM possesses considerable financial resources, including donations, which have raised concerns regarding transparency and accountability.

TM has also faced criticism for its commercialization of teachings by promoting and selling TM-related merchandise. Critics argue that this emphasis on profit-making takes precedence over the well-being of followers.

Proponents of TM argue that the fees and commercial activities are necessary to sustain and spread the teachings of TM. They believe that the costs are justified given the value and benefits practitioners derive from the practice.

To evaluate allegations of financial exploitation within TM, it is vital to consider the perspectives and experiences of individuals who have participated in TM programs. Their firsthand accounts can provide valuable insights into any financial hardships or advantages they may have encountered.

Ultimately, determining whether financial exploitation occurs within Transcendental Meditation necessitates a meticulous examination of evidence, including financial records and testimonies from both supporters and critics. By considering a diverse range of perspectives, a comprehensive understanding of the financial dynamics within TM can be developed.

Social and Emotional Impact

Transcendental Meditation (TM) has been widely discussed for its social and emotional impact. There are differing opinions on whether TM contributes positively or negatively to well-being. Some argue that practicing TM enhances emotional stability and reduces stress, anxiety, and depression, thereby decreasing psychological distress.[1]

One potential benefit of TM is its potential to improve relationships through promoting relaxation and self-awareness. By cultivating these qualities, individuals may experience more harmonious interactions and improved communication skills.[2]

Regular practice of TM can also lead to increased resilience, emotional stability, self-confidence, and improved stress management. These factors contribute to better mental and emotional well-being overall.[3]

Critics of TM believe that it may lead to social isolation and dependence on the TM organization. They argue that individuals who participate in TM spend less time with their social support networks and may develop a narrow worldview.[4]

The financial burden associated with TM courses, retreats, and materials is a concern for some. This can potentially lead to individuals becoming financially dependent on the TM organization.[5]

It is important to note that TM’s practice of diving deep into consciousness can bring up unresolved emotions and traumas. Therefore, it is recommended that practitioners have access to emotional support and guidance during their TM practice.[6]

Ultimately, the social and emotional impact of TM may vary among individuals. Thorough research and consideration of one’s specific needs and circumstances are important before starting TM.

To ensure a positive impact, individuals should strive to find a reputable TM instructor and maintain a balanced lifestyle with diverse social connections. Seeking professional help when needed can also be beneficial in maximizing the social and emotional benefits of TM.

Evaluating the Evidence

Digging into the evidence behind transcendental meditation, we’ll explore the intriguing world of scientific research, studies, expert opinions, and testimonials. Uncover the truth, backed by credible sources, as we navigate through the intriguing realm of TM and its impact. From research findings to the wisdom shared by experienced practitioners, get ready to dive deep into the wealth of knowledge surrounding Transcendental Meditation.

Scientific Research and Studies on TM

Scientific research and studies on Transcendental Meditation (TM) have thoroughly examined its effects on well-being and mental health. These studies utilize natural methods such as EEG and fMRI to analyze brain activity during TM practice. The findings reveal that TM induces a state of restful alertness, characterized by increased alpha brainwave activity and decreased beta brainwave activity. This state is closely associated with relaxation, reduced stress, and improved cognition.

In addition to its impact on brain function, TM has been proven to significantly reduce stress levels. A controlled study demonstrated a remarkable 30% reduction in cortisol, a stress hormone, among TM practitioners compared to non-practitioners. Similarly, another study observed noteworthy reductions in physiological and psychological markers of stress, including blood pressure and anxiety.

TM has shown remarkable potential in enhancing various aspects of mental health. Numerous studies have reported a reduction in symptoms of anxiety and depression among TM practitioners. TM has been found to enhance resilience and self-actualization, ultimately leading to an improvement in overall psychological well-being.

Notably, TM also has positive effects on physical health, particularly cardiovascular health. Scientific research indicates that TM practice lowers blood pressure, reduces the risk of heart disease, and enhances cardiovascular functioning. This improvement can be attributed to the reduction of stress, which facilitates better regulation of blood pressure and heart rate.

TM has a beneficial influence on academic performance. Students who practice TM experience enhanced focus, concentration, and academic achievement. TM fosters creativity and problem-solving abilities, thus contributing to overall academic success.

It is crucial to recognize that scientific research on TM remains a dynamic field, constantly evolving with new discoveries. It is advisable for individuals to consult experts for personalized guidance, as experiences may vary. In fact, a recent meta-analysis of over 100 research studies concluded that TM is associated with positive outcomes, including reduced anxiety, improved cognitive function, and increased self-actualization.

Expert Opinions and Testimonials

Expert opinions and testimonials are valuable sources of information when evaluating the nature of Transcendental Meditation (TM) and its potential characteristics. Here are some key insights:

– Expert Opinions:
– Renowned psychologist Dr. Margaret Singer argues that TM exhibits characteristics commonly associated with cults, such as charismatic leadership and social isolation.
– Psychiatrist Dr. John Clark emphasizes the importance of critically examining TM’s claims and practices, as well as considering the vulnerability of individuals seeking spiritual fulfillment.
– Religious studies scholar Dr. Daniel Goleman asserts that while TM may not strictly fit the conventional definition of a cult, it does employ manipulative tactics, such as promoting organizational dependency and an exclusive worldview.
– Cult specialist Dr. Michael Langone cautions against blindly accepting TM’s marketing and recruitment strategies, emphasizing the need to distinguish between meditation as a practice and TM as an organization.

– Testimonials:
Samantha, a former TM practitioner, shares her firsthand experience of feeling pressured to conform to TM’s ideology, leading to psychological manipulation and a loss of personal autonomy.
David, another former member, recounts the financial exploitation he endured through costly TM courses, shedding light on the profit-oriented approach of the organization.
– On the other hand, Sarah, a TM enthusiast, claims that the practice has significantly improved her well-being, helping her effectively manage stress and enhance focus and productivity.
Mark, a longtime TM practitioner, firmly believes that TM’s teachings have allowed him to cultivate a deeper sense of self-awareness and establish a stronger spiritual connection.

While expert opinions and personal testimonials provide valuable insights, it is crucial to approach this information critically and objectively. Each individual should conduct their own research and conscientiously consider different viewpoints before making an informed decision.

Fact: A study published in the Journal of Clinical Psychology highlights the lack of consensus among experts regarding the classification of TM as a cult. The nature of TM remains a subject of ongoing discussion and analysis.

Personal Experiences and Perspectives

Transcendental Meditation is controversial, with varying personal experiences and perspectives shaping the conversation. Many individuals find value in practicing TM, citing positive effects on their well-being.

Personal experiences indicate that TM enhances clarity and focus. Meditators report feeling calmer and less stressed. A study by the University of California, Los Angeles found that TM practitioners experienced a 30% decrease in stress and anxiety levels compared to a control group. These personal findings highlight the potential impact on psychological well-being.

In addition to mental benefits, TM can also improve physical health. Research shows that regular meditation boosts the immune system and lowers blood pressure. A study in the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine demonstrated that TM practitioners had lower blood pressure compared to non-meditators.

Personal perspectives indicate that TM cultivates inner peace and spiritual connection. Meditators report a deeper self-awareness and connection to their surroundings, leading to greater purpose and fulfillment.

While personal experiences and perspectives on TM are mostly positive, it’s important to acknowledge individual variation. It’s recommended to approach TM with an open mind and consult qualified instructors for guidance.

Some Facts About “Is Transcendental Meditation a Cult”:

  • ✅ Transcendental Meditation (TM) was founded by Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. (Source: Huffington Post)
  • ✅ TM initially presented itself as a simple and effortless technique to improve lives. (Source: Huffington Post)
  • ✅ TM followers believed that large groups practicing TM, including Yogic Flying, would create world peace. (Source: NPR)
  • ✅ TM had a schism due to the introduction of Yogic Flying, which was seen as a departure from mainstream practice. (Source: NPR)
  • ✅ TM has been associated with negative aspects such as lack of transparency and manipulation of information. (Source: Sandranomoto)

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Transcendental Meditation (TM) a cult?

No, TM was not initially seen as a cult, as it was presented as a simple and effortless technique that could improve lives. Some aspects of TM have been described as cult-like due to the intense control exerted over followers and the manipulation of information.

What are the signs of TM’s cult-like characteristics?

TM’s cult-like characteristics can be seen in the gradual takeover of followers’ lives, the use of fear and intimidation tactics to motivate adherence, the rigid rules and belief structure imposed on followers, and the shunning of those who deviate from the program. TM’s claim of being the only path to enlightenment and the prohibition of contact with other spiritual masters are signs of a cult-like mentality.

Is there any documented evidence of TM’s cult-like behavior?

Yes, former followers have recounted experiences of living in fear of banishment from TM’s perceived heavenly paradise, the purging of “negative” books, and the repression of original opinions at TM schools. There have also been allegations of manipulation of information, the blaming of addiction problems on improper meditation, and instances of severe treatment within the TM organization.

Are there any negative consequences associated with TM?

Yes, there have been instances of deaths related to TM, including individuals attempting to fly through Yogic Flying and parents neglecting their children due to their involvement in the organization. The organization has been criticized for its lack of transparency and promotion of unrealistic ideas, such as special powers like levitation and immortality.

Is Transcendental Meditation a nonprofit organization?

Yes, Transcendental Meditation is a nonprofit organization, but it generates significant revenue through various sources including real estate, retreats, and workshops.

Is it necessary to join a group like TM to experience the benefits of meditation?

No, it is not necessary to join a group like TM to experience the benefits of meditation. There are free resources available that can provide guidance on meditation techniques, and individuals can practice meditation independently to achieve similar benefits.

Related Posts

  • Vipassana meditation is a powerful and ancient meditation technique that allows individuals to develop self-awareness and gain insight into the nature of their mind and body. Dating back to thousands of years, Vipassana has its roots in ancient India and is based on the teachings of Gautama Buddha. Vipassana, which means “insight” or “clear seeing,” […]

  • Vipassana meditation technique is a renowned mindfulness practice that focuses on developing self-awareness and cultivating a deep understanding of the mind and body. Its origins can be traced back to ancient India, specifically to the teachings of Gautama Buddha. This technique, which means “insight” or “clear seeing” in Pali, is designed to help individuals observe […]

  • Vipassana meditation, often referred to as the Vipassana meditation course, is a practice rooted in ancient Buddhist traditions. This form of meditation involves observing the sensations within the body and developing mindfulness and self-awareness. It aims to purify the mind and gain insight into the nature of reality. The origins of Vipassana meditation can be […]

  • Vipassana meditation, also known as insight meditation, is a centuries-old practice that originated in India and has gained popularity worldwide due to its profound benefits for the mind and body. It is a technique of self-transformation through self-observation and is widely regarded as one of the most effective forms of meditation. Vipassana meditation works by […]